An ‘Inequitable Approach to Equity’: Princeton Parents Protest Dumbing Down of Math Curricula

Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on linkedin
Share on pinterest
Share on facebook
Share on twitter

This is a letter from six parents of Princeton Regional Public Schools District students protesting changes in the standards and sequence of math courses in middle and high school. The changes, which the parents describe as a “cover-up,” were designed by Rowen University professor Eric Milou under the direction of new superintendent Carol Kelley and the school board; they rely heavily on the controversial “California Framework.” The parents also criticize the initiative to de-track all math courses and a consulting group’s definition of “equity,” which translates to “equal outcomes for every student, without exception.”

We write to express our serious concerns about the direction the Princeton Public School system is taking under the current administration and the new superintendent, Dr. Carol Kelley.  We first became aware of this new direction when the district formed a “Math Committee” this spring to consider changes to the math curriculum.  The committee was charged with considering changes proposed by an outside consultant hired by the district, Dr. Eric Milou. The proposed reforms included “detracking” the math curriculum through 10th grade, so that all students—regardless of aptitude or interest in math—would be taught the same content.  Algebra 1 would no longer be taught to 7th and 8th grade students; instead all students would take Algebra 1 in 9th grade.  The Princeton High School math curriculum would end with Precalculus; the existing Calculus courses would no longer be taught.  It is disadvantaged students who stand to lose the most from this “leveling down” approach; families of means can and will seek such instruction elsewhere if it is not provided by the public schools.

Even more disturbing, in response to a parent outcry opposing these changes, district administrators engaged in what can only be called a cover-up, by denying that the Math Committee was formed to consider Dr. Milou’s recommendations, by denying that Dr. Milou even made recommendations, and by releasing only a heavily redacted version of Dr. Milou’s report that conceals his recommendations.  It is shocking to us that the leadership of the district is dissembling like this.  We have detailed all of this in a report available by clicking here

The district’s Math Committee fiasco is an instance of a broader problem: the lack of transparency, accountability, and good governance on the part of those running our schools.  For example, in the past year alone, the district has spent hundreds of thousands of dollars of taxpayer funds on outside consultants, many of whom are pushing ideological agendas. Under Dr. Kelley, media and leadership consulting fees in this year alone are 30% more than the previous two years combined. The district paid $47,000 to Dr. Milou, a well-known detracking advocate, to advise on the math program.  It paid $92,000 to hire a consulting firm, Performance Fact, to advise on a new strategic plan centered on equity. Performance Fact informed the Princeton community that equity demands “equal outcomes, without exception” for every student.  That extreme and simplistic approach to equity leads naturally to the district’s new “leveling down” approach.  Yet a recent community forum on the Strategic Plan (one of only two opportunities so far scheduled for public input) was devoted to an abstract and unhelpful discussion of the “ideal graduate” of our schools rather than to concrete actions for addressing problems of equity.

Concerned community members should write to the Board of Education and demand transparency and accountability, beginning with the release of the full report by Dr. Milou on the math curriculum.

For more information, and to join our efforts, please email us at [email protected]

Eleanor Hubbard

Jill North

Jai Subrahmanyam

Rachael Winfree

Share on facebook
Facebook
Share on twitter
Twitter
Share on linkedin
LinkedIn
Share on pinterest
Pinterest

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.